Skip to content
tracktoFIRELearn finance

100% private. Everything you enter is worked out and saved in this browser, never sent to a server. Nobody else can see your numbers, not even the makers of this app.

All topics

Investing with a broker

Moving to another broker

Shares and ETFs can usually move to another broker without being sold, so there's no tax on gains to pay and no time out of the market. Many brokers charge nothing either way; some charge for each holding that leaves.

You've found a cheaper broker, or yours has raised its fees, or you're moving country. Selling everything to start again elsewhere would hand part of your gains to the tax office, cost a spread both ways, and leave your money out of the market while it moves. A transfer moves the shares and ETFs themselves, so you keep them as they are. In the UK it's called an in-specie transfer, in Germany a Depotübertrag.

Investing for financial independence takes decades, and the broker that suits you today may not suit you then. So whether you can leave without selling is part of what a broker costs.

Selling or moving

Many countries tax the profit you make when you sell (see tax on gains), even if you buy the same ETFs again the same day.

You hold €20,000 of ETFs bought for €15,000. Selling them with 25% tax on gains costs €1,250 in tax. Moving them as 3 holdings (each fund or share you own is one holding) at €25 each costs €75.

How it works

  • Open an account at the new broker first. Then either the new broker asks for your holdings or you ask the one you're leaving to send them, depending on the brokers.
  • Only what the new broker offers can move; anything else has to be sold first.
  • Some brokers take holdings only from some banks or countries, or let you move them out only all at once.
  • Only whole units move, so fractional shares are sold, and you may owe tax on that sale.
  • It takes from a few days to several weeks, and what's moving can't be sold in the meantime.

What it costs

Many brokers charge nothing either way. Some charge for each holding that leaves, from about €20 to €100, sometimes with a cap, and a few pass on what the exchange charges. To win you over, the receiving broker sometimes pays back what the old one charged.

Transfer cost = number of holdings × fee per holding, at most the cap

15 holdings at €50 each cost €750; with a cap of €160, only €160. A portfolio of two or three ETFs is cheap to move from any broker.

Keep your purchase records

Tax on gains is worked out from what you paid, so the purchase prices need to travel with the holdings. Between brokers in the same country they usually do; across borders they often don't, and then it's up to you to show them. Germany shows both cases: its banks must pass the purchase data to each other, and when it's missing, as after a transfer from abroad, a bank withholds tax as if 30% of the sale price were gain, which you can correct in your tax return.

In Croatia, where gains on investments held for more than two years aren't taxed, selling and buying again restarts the two years and resets the price you paid, which a transfer doesn't. Sold within two years, the ETFs in the example above would cost €600 in tax there, at 12%.

In the UK

To move a Stocks and Shares ISA, ask the new provider to transfer it, which should take no more than 30 calendar days. Withdrawing the money to pay it in elsewhere isn't a transfer: it leaves the ISA's tax-free wrapper.

In the broker comparison

Each card's Transfers show whether a broker takes holdings from another broker (Transfer in) and lets you move them out (Transfer out), what each costs, and any limits, such as "Only all holdings at once". They're paid once, if ever, so the yearly cost leaves them out. A broker that charges a lot to leave, or doesn't let you leave without selling, makes it costly to move to a cheaper broker later.

Where you'll see it