Good years and bad
The order of returns
A fall in the first years after you stop does far more harm than the same fall later, because you sell while prices are low. Also called sequence of returns risk.
Two people retire with €1,000,000 each and take €40,000 a year in today's money, 4% of what they start with. Over ten years they get exactly the same returns, in opposite order. At the end, one has €312,457 more than the other.
Left alone, those ten years turn €1,000,000 into €1,603,309 in either order. Once you're living off your investments, the order matters a lot. After a fall you have to sell more to cover the same spending, and what you sold can't take part in the recovery.
| Year | Bad years first | Bad years last |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | −25%€720k | +20%€1.15m |
| 2 | −10%€612k | +12%€1.25m |
| 3 | +5%€601k | +10%€1.33m |
| 4 | +10%€617k | +8%€1.39m |
| 5 | +15%€663k | +12%€1.51m |
| 6 | +12%€698k | +15%€1.69m |
| 7 | +8%€711k | +10%€1.82m |
| 8 | +10%€738k | +5%€1.87m |
| 9 | +12%€781k | −10%€1.64m |
| 10 | +20%€890k | −25%€1.2m |
Why the first years matter most
Michael Kitces looked at US returns since 1871 for a mix of 60% stocks and 40% bonds (2008). How much each 30-year retirement could safely take out followed the mix's return after inflation over the first 15 years very closely, a correlation of 0.91, while its return over all 30 years matched far less clearly. The worst time to retire in Bengen's tests, the late 1960s, fits: high inflation and flat markets hit in the first years (see the safe withdrawal rate).
What helps
- A lower withdrawal rate, so a bad start takes a smaller bite.
- Some income in the first years: part-time work, rent, or a pension that starts early.
- Spending a little less after a bad year.
- A few years of spending in cash or bonds, so you don't have to sell stocks after a fall, or a bond tent: fewer stocks around the day you stop and more again later (see building a portfolio).
The risk starts before your last working day: a fall in the last years before you stop lowers what you start with. Early in your saving years, the same fall works the other way, since what you invest buys more while prices are low.
In the calculator
The odds in Market volatility include this risk, since each simulated run has its own order of returns. "Your odds" says around what age the runs that ran out typically did, and "Odds by stop age" shows how much stopping a year or two later helps. See market volatility and the odds.
Where you'll see it
- FIRE calculatorMarket volatility: Your odds and Odds by stop age