Investing with a broker
What investing costs
Fund charges and broker fees are the one part of investing you can be sure of, and what they take never grows for you again. Over 30 years, 1% a year leaves a sum invested once about a quarter smaller than it would have grown, whatever the return.
Two people put €10,000 into share funds, then €6,000 a year for 30 years. Their markets are the same, 7% a year before costs. The only difference is what they pay.
Returns are never certain; costs are, and what they take can't grow for you afterwards. 1% a year sounds small, but shares have grown about 5% a year above inflation over the long run (see expected return): 1% is a fifth of that.
Why small percentages add up
A yearly cost is taken from everything you hold, including the growth of earlier years. So it compounds the way growth does (see compound growth), only against you.
Money you add along the way loses a smaller share, since the cost runs on it for fewer years. Add €6,000 a year to the same €10,000, as the card at the end does, and costs take 18.4% rather than 26%. Try your own numbers there.
What a fund charges
Every fund takes its ongoing charges, the TER, a little each day from its value, so you never get a bill for them; its key information document (KID) lists them. What you really paid shows in the tracking difference, how far the fund fell short of its index (see ETFs).
Funds sold through banks often add a charge to get in and another to get out, and the averages above are yearly charges alone. Counting entry and exit charges too, at the most a fund may take and spread over five years, the average equity fund other than an ETF cost about 1.9% a year from 2020 to 2024. Equity ETFs cost about 0.2% in ongoing charges, and take no entry or exit charge when you buy and sell them on an exchange (ESMA, 2026; see index funds and active funds).
What a broker charges
| Fee | When | Usual form |
|---|---|---|
| Order fee | Each buy or sale | A fixed amount, a percentage or both; free at some brokers |
| Automatic investing | Each savings plan buy | Often free, sometimes a fixed amount or a percentage |
| Custody | Every year | A share of what you hold; none at many online brokers |
| Currency exchange | Buying something in another currency | A markup on the exchange rate, from almost nothing to about 1%, more at some banks |
| Inactivity | After months without trading | A monthly fee, at a few brokers |
| Deposits and withdrawals | Paying in by card, or taking money out | A fee at a few brokers |
| Transfer out | Moving your investments to another broker | Sometimes a fee for each holding moved |
| Robo-adviser or managed portfolio (a service that picks and rebalances funds for you) | Every year, if you choose one | A share of what you hold, on top of the funds' own charges |
The next topics explain custody fees, currency exchange, automatic investing and moving to another broker. On top of these, every buy and sale pays the spread, the small gap between the price to buy and the price to sell, and in the UK there's often a platform fee: a yearly share of what you hold, which some providers cap for shares and ETFs.
Fixed fees or percentages
A fixed fee weighs most on small amounts, a percentage on large ones.
So which broker is cheapest depends on how you invest. For small monthly amounts, the fee on each buy matters most; for a large balance, any fee on what you hold.
Is a broker without fees free?
A broker that charges nothing to buy still has to make money: a markup on currency exchange, more interest on clients' cash than it pays them, part of the fee for lending out their securities, paid plans and extras. Some send every order to one exchange or trading firm of their choosing, whose price can be a little worse than the best elsewhere: a cost you never see on a bill.
Payment for order flow, where a market maker (a firm that always offers prices to buy and sell) pays a broker to send it the broker's clients' orders, is banned in the EU. The ban took effect in March 2024; countries where it was already common, such as Germany, could allow it until 30 June 2026, and since then it applies everywhere.
Going deeper: costs and your withdrawal rate
Costs don't stop when you stop working. They come out of the money you live on, so they lower how much you can safely take out each year (see the safe withdrawal rate), but not by the whole fee. In US data for 30-year retirements, Gordon Pye (2001) found that a 1% yearly cost lowered a 4% safe rate to about 3.5%, and Michael Kitces (2012) to about 3.6%: only about half a percentage point. The fee is a share of what's left, and in the bad years that decide the safe rate, what's left shrinks, and the fee with it.
Those studies looked at 30-year retirements, which run the money down. An early retirement of 50 years or more has to live mostly on what the money earns rather than on the money itself, so the same fee takes more off the safe rate, closer to the whole fee.
In the broker comparison
- Each broker's yearly cost adds up twelve buys of what you invest each month (through automatic investing where it's offered, otherwise as ordinary orders) and custody on what you'd hold on average over the year. The list is ranked by it, and under each cost is its share of what you'd hold by year end: what you've invested already plus the year's buys.
- Not counted: fund charges, which are the same for the same ETF at every broker (the FIRE calculator counts them); currency exchange, since ETFs bought in your own currency need none; and fees for selling, deposits, transfers or extras.
In the calculator
Enter your funds' ongoing charges under Fund costs, in Assumptions; the expected return is then the return before them. In a new plan they start at 0, so the results count no fund costs until you enter yours. The calculator takes them from your investments every year, before and after you stop, and takes half of them off your withdrawal rate, in line with what the research above found for 30-year retirements; it does the same with a yearly tax on investments. Pension savings pay neither fund costs nor that tax.
In What if, the Try a change card has a slider for fund costs that shows how far full FIRE moves as you drag it. For a plan that pays them, Reach full FIRE by age can suggest a line such as "Cut fund costs to 0.20% a year".
Try it
What a yearly cost takes over the years, with the growth that money would have earned.
Where you'll see it
- FIRE calculatorYour plan, Assumptions: Fund costs, and What if, Try a change
- Broker comparisonEach broker, the yearly cost and How it's worked out