Good years and bad
Market volatility and the odds
Markets never grow at a steady rate, so a plan can work in one future and fail in another. Testing it in hundreds of simulated markets shows how likely your money is to last.
A plan with a steady 7% a year gives one answer, but no market has ever grown at a steady 7%. And as the order of returns shows, when the bad years come matters as much as how bad they are. So rather than "when can I stop?", the better question is "if I stop then, how likely is my money to last?"
How a simulation answers it
A simulation tries many possible futures and counts how often the plan works. Each year's return is drawn at random around the expected return, and the plan is run again and again. The method is called Monte Carlo: the mathematician Stanisław Ulam came up with it in 1946, playing solitaire while ill, and his Los Alamos colleague Nicholas Metropolis named it after the casino in Monaco.
How far the drawn returns stray from the expected return is set by the yearly volatility, about 15% for a global stock index (see risk and return). They're drawn from a bell curve, though real markets have more extreme years than a bell curve allows.
Reading the odds
"In 92% of simulated markets" means the money lasted in 92% of those runs. It isn't a forecast: it's how often the plan held up in markets like the ones the simulation draws. In real life you'd adjust along the way, and spending a little less in bad years lifts the odds a lot. Why not aim for 100%? A plan that has to survive every imaginable market keeps you working for years against disasters that may never come. And runs that fail often fail late, after decades of spending, with time to change course.
Going deeper: history or simulation
Historical tests, like Bengen's and the Trinity study's (see the safe withdrawal rate), replay real sequences of past returns: every bad decade really happened, but there are few of them, especially for 50-year retirements, and one country's past may not repeat. Monte Carlo invents as many futures as you like, but they're only as realistic as the assumptions behind them. Either way success is a yes or no: running out at 94 counts the same as running out at 70.
In the calculator
- New plans start with market volatility off, so Summary assumes your expected return every year. Pick one as "Yearly volatility" under Assumptions or in Market volatility: Off, 10% for a mix of stocks and bonds, 15% for global stocks or 20% for a single country.
- It follows your plan until you stop working, then simulates the years after 500 times, the typical run growing at your expected return. A run succeeds if the money lasts to the end of your plan.
- The odds show in whole percent, rounded down, so 90% always means at least 9 in 10.
- Because a yes or no hides how a plan fails, "Your odds" also says around what age the runs that ran out typically did, so you can see whether failing means 70 or 94.
- The same 500 markets are used every time, so every stop age is compared on equal terms.
- It aims for the money to last in at least 9 in 10 runs. If you stop as soon as your investments reach your target and it lasts less often, your full FIRE age is the first later age at which it lasts at least that often. More volatility can move the age you stop, never the target, as "What it does to your plan" shows.
- In Projected wealth, the likely range is where 8 in 10 simulated markets end up.
What it leaves out
Each year's return is independent of the last, so it misses runs of good or bad years and the recoveries history shows: the US market was back at its February 2020 peak within six months and at its 2007 peak about five and a half years later, while Japan's took 34 years to pass its 1989 peak (prices alone, before dividends). Researchers disagree whether that makes simulations like this too careful or not careful enough. Inflation stays steady, though an inflation shock was behind the worst time to retire in US history. Your spending doesn't react to markets, and only your investments and pension savings swing.
Where you'll see it
- FIRE calculatorSummary, the line under its heading and the odds under Projected wealthMarket volatility: Your odds, Odds by stop age and What it does to your plan