Property
Rental property
The rent isn't what a rental earns you. What it really brings in after running costs, the mortgage and tax, how its yield compares with investing, and whether to keep it or sell it when you stop working.
A flat that rents for €1,000 a month sounds like €12,000 a year. With a mortgage still running, you might keep only €162 of it.
Rent can pay part of your living costs for as long as you own the flat, like a pension that has already started. But what pays for your life is the cash left after everything the flat costs, not the rent.
What comes off the rent
- Running costs: repairs, insurance, management, the building's shared charges, property tax and empty months (a single empty month is 8.3% of a year's rent). Landlords' actual accounts, studied over decades, put repairs, maintenance, management and insurance alone at about 27 to 32% of the rent (rental buildings in Amsterdam: Eichholtz, Korevaar, Lindenthal and Tallec, 2021), and costs including property taxes at about a third (homes owned by Oxford and Cambridge colleges: Chambers, Spaenjers and Steiner, 2021). Empty months come on top.
- The mortgage payment: interest and repayment of the loan together.
- Tax. Many countries tax the profit: rent less running costs and mortgage interest, since repaying the loan isn't a cost. Others tax the rent itself, or the property's value (see How rent is taxed, below).
| First year | Loan paid off | |
|---|---|---|
| Rent | €12,000 | €12,000 |
| Running costs, 30% | €3,600 | €3,600 |
| Tax, 20% of the profit | €880 | €1,680 |
| Mortgage payment | €7,358 | €0 |
| Left for you | €162 | €6,720 |
Once the loan is gone, so is the payment, and with it the interest that lowered the tax. The tax rises, but far more is left.
Gross and net yield
A yield is a year's income as a share of what something is worth. Listings quote the gross yield:
Gross yield = a year's rent ÷ the property's value
The flat above yields 4.8% gross. After running costs and tax, before any mortgage, its net yield is 2.7%. That's its income alone, like a fund's dividends, so it compares with a withdrawal rate: what you take out of investments each year (below). To compare it with an investment's whole return, add any rise in the flat's price.
The rest of the return
Each payment also pays down the loan, and the flat's price may rise.
Only the €162 can be spent. The rest pays no bills until you sell or the loan is gone. That 2% rise includes inflation: if prices in general rise 2% too, the €5,000 only keeps the flat's value level in today's money. And the borrowing that lifts the return on your money also deepens a loss: with €100,000 of the flat's €250,000 borrowed, a 10% fall in its price takes 16.7% of your money in it (see mortgages).
How rent is taxed
- Croatia, in 2026: a long-term let is taxed at 12% of the rent less a flat 30% for costs, so 8.4% of the rent, whatever you actually spend on the flat, and with no deduction for mortgage interest. With a quarter of the rent in running costs and no mortgage, that's about 11.2% of the profit. Letting to tourists pays a yearly tax per bed instead, set by the municipality. Since 2025 towns also charge a yearly property tax per square metre, but not on a flat let for at least ten months of the year to a tenant who lives there, with the lease reported to the tax office.
- Germany: rent is taxed as income, after running costs, mortgage interest and the building's yearly depreciation.
- The Netherlands: a let home that isn't your own is taxed as part of your wealth in Box 3, not on its rent (see yearly tax on investments).
- The UK, in 2026: individual landlords can't deduct mortgage interest from the rent; since April 2020 they get a tax reduction of 20% of it instead. From April 2027, in England, Wales and Northern Ireland, rent is taxed at its own rates, 2 points higher than other income, and the reduction rises to 22%.
Keep it or sell it when you stop working
Paid off, the flat brings in €6,720 a year. At a 3.5% withdrawal rate, it would take €192,000 invested to pay the same: that's how much it takes off your FIRE number while you keep it.
On these numbers alone, keeping pays more once the net yield is above the withdrawal rate less the selling costs:
Keeping pays more when net yield > withdrawal rate × (1 − selling costs)
Here that's 3.5% × 0.93, about 3.3%. What the arithmetic leaves out:
- Rent that rises faster or slower than prices.
- Tax on the sale (see tax on gains): in Croatia a gain on property is usually tax-free after two years, in Germany after ten.
- The flat itself. Kept, it's still yours: a reserve you could sell later or leave to someone, which the rent alone doesn't count.
- The work of being a landlord, which doesn't stop when your job does.
- The spread. A sale's proceeds can go into thousands of companies (see diversification), where a flat is one building on one street.
What can go wrong
- A tenant who stops paying, a new roof or a few empty months can take a year's cash, where one company's trouble barely moves a global fund.
- When you need some of the money in a bad year, you can't sell a tenth of a flat, and selling all of it takes months and several percent of the price.
- Rent controls, tax changes and limits on letting to tourists can change what a flat brings in after you buy it.
Going deeper: how well has property paid?
The widest study, "The Rate of Return on Everything, 1870–2015" by Jordà, Knoll, Kuvshinov, Schularick and Taylor (2019), built housing returns for 16 advanced economies from national price and rent indices: about 7% a year after inflation on average, about the same as shares, with less than half their swings (a yearly standard deviation of 10% against 22%). Compounded, as the studies below report their returns, that's about 6.6% a year for housing against 4.6% for shares.
Studies of real buildings, with their actual costs and property taxes, find less. Rental buildings in Paris returned 4.0% a year after inflation from 1809 to 1943 and in Amsterdam 4.8% from 1900 to 1979, almost all of it rent rather than rising prices (Eichholtz and colleagues, 2021). Homes owned by Oxford and Cambridge colleges returned 2.3% a year, after inflation and costs, from 1901 to 1983 (Chambers, Spaenjers and Steiner, 2021). Most of what property paid was the rent, and one flat's result is far less certain than an index of thousands.
In the calculator
The "Rental property" chip under "Does any of this apply to you?" adds the Real estate card with a rental, and Add a property adds more. Besides its value and mortgage, a rental asks for the Monthly rent, Running costs (as a % of rent), Tax on rental profit, Value growth, Rent growth and what happens At FIRE: "Keep and collect rent" or "Sell and invest", which also asks for Selling costs. Value growth and Rent growth are yearly rises that include inflation. The calculator starts them at 3% and 2%, with inflation at 2%, so the rent keeps pace with prices and the value grows a little faster; Running costs start at 30%. A note under the fields says what the rent leaves now.
- While you work, what the rent leaves goes into your investments on top of what you invest, so leave it out of Amount you invest. A rental that costs more than it brings in takes the difference from them.
- Kept, its net rent counts toward your target year by year, with the step up once the loan is paid off, like a pension that starts later. From the plan's last age (Plan until age) on, it counts that age's rent for good, worked out as if rent had grown no faster than inflation. Its equity never counts toward FIRE, only its rent.
- Sold, its value less the mortgage and Selling costs joins your investments when you stop (on the Barista FIRE route, when you go part time). No tax on gains is taken from it, so put any tax on the sale into Selling costs. Before the sale, the plan already counts what it would bring when it checks whether you've reached FIRE.
- Tax on rental profit starts at 0% and is taken from the rent less running costs and mortgage interest. Where the tax is a share of the rent itself, leave Tax on rental profit at 0% and add the tax to Running costs instead: 8.4% of the rent for a long-term let in Croatia.
- After FIRE, Your properties, shows the equity of all your properties, your rentals' cash flow today taken together, and the age the last mortgage is paid off. A rental in the money tracker shows up under Real estate, in Rentals in your net worth, as a chip that adds it with its value and mortgage; you add the rent.
In the money tracker
Under Property, each rental has its value, Mortgage left, Mortgage payment, rent and running costs. What the rent leaves after its costs and mortgage payment counts as income each month, or as a cost under Other when it's below zero, so put any tax on the rent in its running costs. In your net worth, a rental counts at its market value less its mortgage, as a home does, but it stays in Without your home, since you could sell it without moving.
Where you'll see it
- FIRE calculatorYour plan, Real estate, and After FIRE, Your properties
- Money trackerYour money, Property