Investing basics
Index funds and active funds
An index fund buys a whole market for a small yearly cost. Active funds try to pick the winners and charge more for it: over ten years, almost nine in ten active equity funds sold in Europe fell behind or closed.
Actively managed equity funds are pools of savers' money in which professionals pick shares to beat the market. Of every 100 on sale in Europe at the start of 2016, 44 had closed or merged into other funds ten years later. Most of the rest were still open but had earned less than index funds investing in the same kind of shares, which buy a whole market rather than pick from it. Only 11 had stayed open and earned more (Morningstar European Active/Passive Barometer, Full-Year 2025). The index funds didn't need to be clever to come out ahead. They needed to be cheap.
What an index is
An index is a list of companies chosen by fixed rules, such as all large and mid-sized companies in developed countries. Most weigh each company by its market value, the share price times the number of shares, so the largest count most.
| Index | Covers | Number of companies |
|---|---|---|
| MSCI World | 23 developed countries | 1,249 |
| MSCI ACWI | 23 developed and 24 emerging countries | 2,414 |
| FTSE All-World | 49 developed and emerging countries | 4,204 |
| S&P 500 | Large US companies | 500 |
Others cover one region, such as the STOXX Europe 600 (600 European companies), and some follow bonds rather than shares.
What an index fund is
An index fund buys everything in an index, in the same proportions, and sells you units of the fund. A fund following the S&P 500 holds all 500 companies, the largest the most, so each unit is a small slice of all of them. Since it copies rather than chooses, it needs no team of analysts, and what you get is the index's return less a small yearly cost. Many index funds are ETFs, whose units trade on a stock exchange like shares; those on world shares charge from 0.05% to about 0.20% a year. Others are ordinary funds, bought from the fund company (see ETFs for how to choose).
The idea was mocked at first. When John Bogle's Vanguard launched the first index fund for ordinary investors in 1976, rivals called it Bogle's folly. By the end of 2024, index funds and ETFs held 41% of the money in the EU equity funds that the European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA) tracks.
How often index funds come out ahead
Of the 6,860 active equity funds on sale in Europe at the start of 2016, only 11.4% both survived to the end of 2025 and beat the index funds investing in the same things (Morningstar, Full-Year 2025). Over five years it was 15.4%, over three 19.9%, and in a single year, 2025, 31.2%: in a typical year about seven in ten active funds trail, and the longer you look, the fewer stay ahead.
These counts include the funds that later closed, which is what makes them honest. Count only the funds still open, as fund ads tend to, and the record looks far better, since the losers were quietly shut or merged. That's survivorship bias. Index funds close too, but less often: 64.8% were still open after ten years, against 55.8% of active ones.
Why index funds come out ahead
The economist William Sharpe pointed out the arithmetic in 1991. Everyone who holds the whole market in its proportions earns the market's return before costs. Everyone else together, active funds, hedge funds and people picking shares themselves, holds the rest of the market, so before costs they too earn its return on average. After their higher costs, the average actively managed euro must earn less. Some active funds can win, but only at the expense of other active investors, and no one knows in advance which.
And the costs are large. In 2024 active equity funds in the EU cost 1.28% a year on average, against 0.21% for equity ETFs. From 2015 to 2024 active funds returned 7.6% a year after costs, against 9.3% for index funds (ESMA, Costs and Performance of EU Retail Investment Products 2025, March 2026). On €10,000 over those ten years, that's €20,803 against €24,333. Costs also predict which active funds do best: over ten years, 19.0% of the cheapest fifth beat index funds, against 3.7% of the most expensive fifth (Morningstar). See what investing costs.
Winners don't stay winners
The active funds that beat the index in one stretch are rarely the ones that beat it in the next. Of the world equity funds sold in Europe that were in the top half of their group over the five years to 2020, only 16% stayed there over the next five, where chance alone would keep about half (S&P Dow Jones Indices, SPIVA Europe Persistence Scorecard, Year-End 2025). Picking the next decade's winning fund is as hard as picking its winning shares.
Going deeper: where active funds do better
The gap isn't the same everywhere. Over the ten years to 2025, 31.5% of active bond funds in Europe beat their index rivals, and 44.3% in euro corporate bonds, where managers choose which bonds to hold and for how long. In emerging-market shares it was 19.6%, and active funds do better with small companies than with large ones. At the other end, only 3.8% of active funds buying large eurozone companies came out ahead, and 5.1% of those buying large US companies (Morningstar, Full-Year 2025). Even where active funds do best, most fall short: what index funds have isn't skill but low cost.
In the calculator
Under Assumptions, your expected return is the growth of the index a fund follows over the long run, before costs. What your fund charges goes under Fund costs: the ongoing charges in its key information document (KID), 0.05 to 0.25% a year for an index ETF and often over 1% for a fund sold by a bank.
In the broker comparison
A fund's own charges are the same at every broker, so the comparison leaves them out. "Buying an ETF", under each broker's Fees, is the broker's own fee for an order, on top of what the fund charges.
Where you'll see it
- FIRE calculatorYour plan, Assumptions: Expected return and Fund costs
- Broker comparisonEach broker, Fees: Buying an ETF