Investing basics
Lump sum or bit by bit
Investing a sum all at once has beaten spreading it over months about two times in three, since markets rise more often than they fall. Spreading it out costs a little on average and protects against the worst timing.
You've sold an inherited flat, or a bonus has landed: €50,000 to invest. All of it today, or a bit each month? If markets fall next week, investing it all at once will hurt. If they rise, waiting will. History gives a clear answer on average, and a softer one about how it feels.
Investing from each pay is a different question
Investing part of each salary as it arrives is investing money as you have it: there's no sum to decide about. Holding back a sum you already have and feeding it in over months is a choice, often called cost averaging (dollar-cost averaging in the US), and it has a cost. This topic is about that choice.
What history shows
Across markets and decades, investing a sum at once has come out ahead about two times in three.
- Vanguard took a mix of 60% shares and 40% bonds and compared investing a sum at once with spreading it over 12 months, then holding for ten years, starting in every month of the record. Investing at once came out ahead 67% of the time in the US (1926 to 2011) and the UK (1976 to 2011) and 66% in Australia (1984 to 2011), ending on average 2.3%, 2.2% and 1.3% higher. Against spreading it over 36 months, it won about nine times in ten in the US (Vanguard, 2012).
- For world shares (MSCI World, 1976 to 2022), investing at once beat spreading over three months 68% of the time, measured a year later; in euros, from 1998, 66% (Vanguard, 2023).
Why investing at once usually wins
Markets rise more often than they fall: from 1976 to 2022 US shares beat cash about three times in four (Vanguard, 2023). Money waiting to go in earns only cash rates, so spreading it out wins only when prices fall during those months, which no one can know in advance.
The case for spreading it out
In bad years, spreading it out does better. Take the bad end of history, the result only one starting month in twenty fell below: a year on, $100,000 put into world shares at once had become $82,947, and spread over three months, $85,906 (Vanguard, 2023). It's insurance against the worst timing, paid for with a little less on average.
It also helps with regret. Someone who would sell if prices fell right after investing everything, or who would never invest at all for fear of that, does better spreading it out. A common way is equal parts each month for six to twelve months, set up once through automatic investing so the news doesn't decide. And spreading it out still beats keeping the money in cash: in Vanguard's 2023 study it did 69% of the time.
The cost-average myth
Buying the same amount each month gets you more units when prices are low and fewer when they're high, so you pay less per unit on average than the average of the prices. It still doesn't make spreading out a sum beat investing it at once, as automatic investing shows with an example.
Time in the market
Waiting for a better moment rarely works, since the best days tend to come right after the worst. Of the ten best days for US shares from 2006 to 2025, six came within two weeks of the ten worst. Someone fully invested over those 20 years earned 11.0% a year; missing the ten best days cut that to 6.6%, and missing the 20 best to 3.8% (J.P. Morgan Asset Management, Guide to Retirement 2026).
Those figures assume you miss only the best days; someone out of the market usually misses some of the worst too, since they come in the same weeks. The lesson holds anyway: no one can reliably step out before the falls and back in before the rises.
Paying yourself first
Many people move money to their investments on payday, before they can spend it, rather than investing what's left at the end of the month, and a savings plan does it without a decision each month. How much you invest matters far more than when (see your savings rate).
In the calculator
A sum you already have goes in Invested today, under Your numbers. The amount you invest is added at the end of each year, so investing it monthly does slightly better than the plan shows.
In the broker comparison
Under How you invest, "Invested each month" is costed as twelve buys a year through each broker's automatic investing where it has some. "Invested already" is what you hold now; custody fees are charged on that plus the year's buys, as held on average over the year.
Where you'll see it
- FIRE calculatorYour plan, Your numbers: Amount you invest
- Broker comparisonHow you invest, Invested each month